Skip to content

Blog · Bid or no bid

How do I know if a tender is worth bidding on?

A tender is worth bidding on when you meet every pass/fail requirement, can prove similar work, and nobody else can obviously prove it better.

A tender is worth bidding on when you meet every pass/fail requirement, the work matches what you already do, you can prove it with recent and similar examples, nobody else can obviously prove it better, and the contract pays back the days the bid will take. If one of these is a clear no, walk away early.

A bid costs days of work, so deciding where to bid, often called the bid/no-bid decision, matters as much as the bid itself. This guide is based on interviews with experienced bid writers, the Procurement Act 2023, and what we see when small businesses use TenderSeal. New to tenders? Start with how to start bidding for public sector tenders.

The decision runs in the same order every time, and each step has its own section below.

The bid/no-bid decision, step by step
  1. Read the specification
  2. Check the pass/fail gates
  3. Read the scoring
  4. Size up the incumbent
  5. Weigh time and money
  6. Bid or walk away

What should I check first?

Check the pass/fail requirements first, because one fail ends your bid before anyone reads your answers.

Start with the specification and the summary: what the project is, the budget and the timeline. The specification is the document that says what the buyer actually wants. In a large tender pack it's often an annex. If the work doesn't match what you do, stop there.

Then go through the pass/fail requirements. Under the Procurement Act 2023 these are called conditions of participation.

  • Turnover. Buyers can set a financial condition, but it has to be proportionate to the contract. The Act sets no fixed ratio (guidance). The "twice the contract value" figure still seen online comes from the old rules, where it was a limit on what buyers could ask for.
  • Insurance. A buyer can't require you to hold the contract's insurance before the contract is awarded. They can ask you to show you'll have it from the start of the contract, for example with a letter from an insurer saying they would cover you, plus your commitment to take it out. The buyer still checks the cover before the contract goes ahead. Cover the law already requires, such as employers' liability, can still be asked for.
  • Accreditations. If the buyer names a standard or certification, they have to accept an equivalent. Check that yours really is one.
  • Lots. Large tenders are often split into lots, smaller parts of the contract. Check whether you can bid for only the lot that suits you, and whether there's a limit on how many lots one supplier can bid for.
  • Time and capacity. Can you write the bid and deliver the work? Above the thresholds, the time you get depends on the tender.
SituationLegal minimum to bid
Bids submitted online, all documents available from the startUsually 25 days
The buyer published a planned procurement notice 40 days to 12 months beforeAs little as 10 days
Some contracts, such as light touch contractsNo minimum
Minimum time to bid, above the thresholds

A failed pass/fail requirement ends the bid. A low score on a scored question is a judgement call.

How do I read the scoring to see if I can win?

Find the evaluation criteria and their weightings, then ask three questions about every criterion.

  1. Can we do it?
  2. Can we prove we've done it?
  3. Can someone else prove they've done it better?

Public buyers need to be able to defend their choice, so they look for proof: recent work, in the same sector, at a similar size, for the same kind of people. A case study that is close but not the same is weaker than it looks. A bid writer we interviewed had trained 50 senior staff at one university. For a tender to train 24 junior staff at another university, he judged that case study of little use.

The third question matters as much as the first two. Coming second wins nothing.

Then look at the weightings. If quality carries most of the marks, your evidence decides it. If price carries most of the marks, check that you can win without working at a loss.

Is it worth bidding against the incumbent?

It depends on how the tender is written.

If the specification reads as if it was written for one company, it probably was. Signs include experience so specific that only the current supplier has it, a method or tool only they use, or a start date that only a supplier already in place could meet. In that case, your time is better spent elsewhere.

If the criteria are open and you are a better fit, it's worth bidding. Incumbents do lose. In one case we know of, the buyer went back out to tender to bring the price down. A new supplier matched the incumbent on quality, came in cheaper and won.

You can check who holds a contract now on Find a Tender, which is free to search. The contract award notice names the supplier and gives the estimated value. The contract details notice that follows shows the contract period, the maximum value and any extension options. Contracts tendered under the old rules, before 24 February 2025, may be on Contracts Finder instead. A Freedom of Information request is a fallback, but buyers can refuse to share values on commercial grounds.

Is the contract worth the time and money?

Only if what you'd earn, weighed against a realistic chance of winning, is more than the bid costs you.

A bid writer we interviewed spends four or five days on a typical bid. Here's a worked example. Say a bid takes you 4 days and your day rate is £500. That's £2,000 of your time before you've won anything. If the contract would earn you £8,000 in margin and you have a one in four chance, the bid is worth about £2,000 to you.

Worked example: is a 4-day bid worth it?
  • Your time on the bid£2,000
  • Margin if you win£8,000
  • Value at a 1 in 4 chance£2,000

Source: Worked example with illustrative figures

That's break even, so only bid if it also brings something else you need, such as a reference in a new sector.

Then check the money in the contract itself.

  • Budget against days. Work out roughly how many days the delivery takes and compare it with the budget. Check what the budget leaves out, such as the cost of finding participants or travel.
  • Payment terms. Public contracts under the Act must pay valid invoices within 30 days, and the same applies to subcontracts under a public contract. A term that says otherwise has no effect. If a contract asks you to wait months, ask why.
  • Location. Travel time is unpaid time. A day on site two hours away is a day plus four hours of travel.

A bid/no-bid checklist you can copy

This checklist brings the steps above together.

Step 1: the gates. Answer yes or no. One no means walk away, or ask a clarification question if the requirement looks out of proportion.

  • We meet the turnover or financial condition.
  • We can have the required insurance in place by the contract start.
  • We hold the accreditations asked for, or an equivalent.
  • The lot rules work for us.
  • We have the time and people to write the bid.

Step 2: can we win it? Answer yes, partly or no.

QuestionWhat to check
FitDoes the specification describe work we already deliver?
ProofDo we have recent, similar examples for the highest-weighted criteria?
CompetitionIs anyone obviously better placed, such as the incumbent or a supplier with a bigger team?
MoneyDo the budget, payment terms and travel work for us?
Cost of biddingIs the contract worth the days the bid will take?
The five checks in step 2

Mostly yes: bid. A no on proof or competition: you're unlikely to win, so walk away unless the bid brings something else you need. Several partly answers: ask your clarification questions first, then decide.

What happens if you bid anyway?

A bid that fails a pass/fail requirement can't win. If you don't meet a condition of participation, the buyer can't award you the contract, even if you're the only bidder.

One of our beta testers kept finding requirements in the fine print she couldn't meet because her business was still too small. She told us that when a line said she didn't qualify, she'd skip it and bid anyway. Her hope was that if nobody else bid, she would still have a chance. If no suitable bids come in, the buyer may start again with different terms, and you write the bid a second time.

If you bid and lose, read your assessment summary. Under the Act, in a competitive tender, every bidder whose tender was assessed gets one before the award notice is published. It shows your scores and the reasons for each criterion, plus information about the winning tender. If your bid failed a pass/fail requirement, or the contract is a direct award or a framework call off, you won't get one.

Can software tell me if a tender is worth bidding on?

Software can do the reading and the first check. The decision stays with you. If you're weighing up a general chatbot instead, see what ChatGPT can and can't do on a tender.

That's how we built the check in TenderSeal, bid writing software for suppliers without a bid team. You first give it your company context in three parts: your company profile (policies, insurance, turnover and certifications), your team (CVs) and your track record (past projects and proposals). These are documents you'd need for any bid anyway. For each tender it then gives you:

  • a confidence score with a short summary of why
  • your key strengths and gaps for this tender (a gap can simply be something you haven't uploaded yet)
  • a check of every eligibility requirement, with reasoning
  • deeper reasoning about the decision
  • a profile of the ideal winning supplier for this contract
  • contradictions and less obvious findings in the tender pack

We tested the check with an experienced bid writer on a handful of tenders, including a couple where he already knew his answer. It matched his own calls closely. One of our beta testers went from about half a day to about 20 minutes to qualify a tender.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need the insurance before I bid?

For tenders under the Procurement Act 2023, a buyer can't require you to hold the contract's insurance before the contract is awarded. You can show you'll have it from the start, for example with a letter from an insurer saying they would cover you, plus your commitment to take it out. Insurance the law already requires is different.

Should I bid if I don't meet one requirement?

If it's a pass/fail requirement, no, unless you can meet it before the contract is awarded (for insurance, by the contract start), or the buyer changes it after a clarification question. If it's a scored requirement, you'll lose marks there, so check you can win them back elsewhere.

How long should a bid/no-bid decision take?

A first pass of about ten minutes tells you whether a tender deserves a closer look: specification and summary, pass/fail requirements, scoring. The detailed check of your evidence comes after that. If the tender fails a pass/fail requirement in the first pass, stop there.

This is general information, not legal advice.

Bring the tender. We’ll help with the rest.

TenderSeal reads the tender, answers your questions about it, and drafts your response to the scorecard.